Mr. Writer I really
don’t know what #Kashmiris really think of India. But believe me we #Indians
have enormous love & respect for them. Your article is a good read and in
the first sight a masterpiece of intellectualism but then one need to go again
through it in the light of facts and logics and not merely on prejudices.
You said “We may not
want them to express their sentiments” but can you list out any such event
where Kashmiris who were supporting Pakistan in Mohali were abused or harmed. I
don’t think so because there was no such incident. That’s secular India for you
where people know, constitutional rights are for each and everyone equally.
You said that BJP has
taken Kashmiris further from us. Is it really so? Look again into the past same
BJP government in centre paid thousands of crores when Kashmir was in floods. Same
BJP Prime Minister spent his Diwali with Kashmiris. Or forget it just tell any
incident where BJP had done any unconstitutional act in Kashmir.
You talked about the
religious divide. Yes there is a religious divide in the nation and this is
because of seculars and liberals. People like you who use words such as Hindu
MLA are the biggest reason for this divide. A MLA is a MLA, representative of
people why are you casting them as Hindu MLA or Muslim MLA. Our constitution has
no such provision of religion based representation. Yet for people like you it
is an easy way to gain popularity and you never hesitate walking over it.
You mentioned about
hostility of Indians towards Kashmiri Muslims. Once again you are wrong people don’t
hate Kashmiri Muslims or Muslims of any other part of India. People hate those
people who are involved in terror attacks in the country. No matter, whether
they are from Kashmir or anywhere else. People just hate them. Apart from it
absence of Kashmiri pundits from your article shows that you keep only one eye
open at a time so as to have a limited view of things.
In matter of Mewar
University I do agree that beating those students was wrong and such acts are
condemnable. But tell me if some people do any such act how fare is it to book
a whole community or a nation for it. Also you need to be more attentive with
news legal action has been initiated against those who spread that rumor.
You also seem to have
problem from AFSPA being imposed on the state. But do you know it was imposed
in 1990 and was not before that. So we need to think why it was imposed over
that state? The answer as much as I know is terrorism, which was at its peak in
early 90s in that state. There was no other solution to that as terror handlers
were not ready to talk without bullets. So they were answered in their language
only. Even then we can say yes we need to have a pure debate over AFSPA but a
debate full of pure facts and logics and not prejudices.
You also talked about
unavailability of justice to Kashmiris. Yes you are true but this is a situation
of whole India. Justice is not an easy thing to get here in whole of the
country. Yet if you talk about Kashmir specially you must have knowledge of
what happened in Machil Encounter case. And if you don’t know go and check first
before spreading rumors.
In last you talked
about anit-muslim nationalism which so far is not evident in the country. Some
incidences have taken place but these are crimes and not a war against the
community you love most. But if you see them in such way only similar crimes
have also taken place against the most hated majority community also. But all
these went unnoticed because seculars and liberals see no value for their life.
You talked about freedom of shouting “Bharat mata ki Jai” and then start
searching politics, religion and cast in it.
I request people like
you to please be liberal with your minds in a real sense and not prejudicially.
Because, just like, half truth is more dangerous than a lie, pseudo liberalism
is more dangerous than communalism.
Request-
1. This article is my
personal opinion and it must not be Secularized, Liberalized and intellectualized.
2. Please ignore
errors in English.
